When it comes to improving your home’s water quality, two key players stand out: water softeners and reverse osmosis (RO) systems. While it’s often believed that buying one of these systems means you won’t need the other, the truth is they solve very different problems and, in many cases, work best when used together.
Whether you’re dealing with hard water, strange tastes, or concerns about contaminants, understanding the role each system plays is the key to making the right choice for your household. In this guide, we’ll break down what each system does, when you need one (or both), and how to get the most out of your water filtration setup.
Purpose of a water softener
A water softener removes excess minerals, primarily calcium and magnesium—that cause hard water. Hard water can lead to scale buildup in pipes and appliances, reduce soap effectiveness, and leave spots on dishes and fixtures. Most softeners use ion exchange to replace hard minerals with sodium or potassium ions, creating soft water that’s easier on your plumbing and your skin.
Learn more: Hard vs. Soft Water: Which Is Better for Your Home and Budget?
What water softeners do well
-
Prevent scale buildup in plumbing and appliances, including water heaters, dishwashers, and washing machines
-
Help appliances run more efficiently and extend their lifespan
-
Improve the performance of soaps and detergents
-
Result in cleaner laundry, smoother skin, and shinier hair
-
Reduce spots on glassware and buildup on faucets
If you’re dealing with the daily hassles of hard water, a water softener can be a game-changer.
Limitations of water softeners
While water softeners are great for tackling hard water issues, they aren’t designed to remove contaminants like chlorine, lead, bacteria, or dissolved solids. For those concerns, pairing your softener with another filtration system gives you more complete water quality protection.
Softeners also add a small amount of sodium or potassium to your water—something to consider if you're on a very low-sodium diet. And like any home system, they do require occasional upkeep, such as topping off the salt or potassium tank.
Still, the long-term benefits of soft water—fewer plumbing repairs, longer appliance life, and better performance from soaps and detergents—far outweigh the costs and inconveniences of untreated hard water.
Common misconceptions
-
One of the biggest misconceptions is that water softeners make water "safer" to drink. While they improve water’s feel and reduce mineral buildup, they don’t filter out harmful contaminants.
-
Another myth is that softened water tastes salty—it doesn’t unless the system is malfunctioning.
-
Lastly, some believe softeners waste a lot of water, but newer systems are designed for efficiency, using significantly less water during regeneration cycles than older units.
Purpose of an RO system
A reverse osmosis system is a water filtration method that removes a wide range of contaminants by pushing water through a semipermeable membrane. This membrane rejects impurities like lead, chlorine, fluoride, nitrates, and even some bacteria, allowing only clean water molecules to pass through. RO systems are typically installed under the kitchen sink and provide very high-quality drinking and cooking water, often through a separate faucet.
What RO systems do well
-
Remove up to 99% of common contaminants, including harmful chemicals, heavy metals.
-
Improve water quality for households on well water or in areas with lower-quality municipal water supplies
Enhance the taste, clarity, and overall appeal of drinking water -
Make beverages like coffee and tea taste noticeably better
Learn more: 5 Best Reverse Osmosis Systems
Limitations of RO systems
Reverse osmosis systems are incredibly effective at filtering water—but they’re typically designed for point-of-use filtration, meaning they’re installed at a single tap (often the kitchen sink). Whole home RO systems can be costly, but in most cases, this level of RO filtration is not necessary. Reverse osmosis doesn’t soften water or protect plumbing and appliances like a whole-house system would, which is why you should pair your RO system with a water softener for complete coverage.
RO systems use water during the filtration process to flush out contaminants. While this is sometimes mistaken for waste, it’s a necessary part of how the system purifies your water. Modern RO systems—especially those with a permeate pump—are much more efficient than older models, reducing water usage significantly.
Because RO removes nearly everything, including minerals, the water may taste different to some people. That’s why many systems now include a remineralization stage to restore healthy minerals and improve taste and balance.
Common misconceptions
-
One common misconception is that RO water is “too pure” or unhealthy because it lacks minerals. In reality, most people get essential minerals from food, not drinking water. Also, many systems add minerals back in in a remineralization stage.
-
Another myth is that RO systems are only necessary for well water. While they’re great for wells, they can also be a smart choice if you have any concerns about contaminants or the taste of your municipal water supply.
-
Finally, some assume RO units are high-maintenance, but regular filter changes and occasional sanitization are usually all that’s required.
Learn more: 3 Tips to Help Maintain Your Reverse Osmosis System
Water softeners vs. reverse osmosis systems: different purposes, complementary solutions
Water softeners remove hardness minerals like calcium and magnesium, which helps prevent scale buildup in pipes and appliances throughout the entire home. RO systems, on the other hand, focus on removing chemical and inorganic contaminants, making them ideal for purifying drinking and cooking water.
When used together, the softener should always come first. Softening the water protects the RO membrane from scaling and dramatically extends its lifespan.
When a water softener is best
A water softener is the right choice when hard water is causing noticeable problems around your home. If you're seeing chalky scale buildup on faucets, spots on dishes, or soap that just doesn’t lather well, chances are your water is high in calcium and magnesium. Over time, hard water can wear out appliances like dishwashers and water heaters, reducing their efficiency and lifespan.
A water softener is ideal for whole-house use, treating all the water that enters your plumbing system. It helps protect everything from your pipes to your skin, making it a great solution for homeowners looking to combat mineral-related issues.
Our recommended water softener: Neo-Pure® High Efficiency Up-Flow Series Water Softener
When an RO system is best
If your primary concern is the quality, safety, or taste of your drinking water, a reverse osmosis system is the way to go. RO systems are especially useful in homes on city water, where chlorine, fluoride, and other additives are common.
They’re also a smart choice if you have health concerns that require minimizing exposure to contaminants like lead or nitrates. Whether you’re brewing coffee, making baby formula, or just want cleaner-tasting water, an RO system delivers highly purified water straight from the tap—perfect for drinking and cooking.
Our recommended RO system: Neo-Pure Residential 4 Stage Full Solution RO System 25 GPD with Alkaline Remineralizer, Permeate Pump
When you need both
A water softener and an RO system often complement each other well. This is especially important for homes with hard water and concerns about chemical or inorganic contaminants, particularly those using well water with high total dissolved solids (TDS).
It's also a smart setup in coastal areas where brackish or seawater intrusion can affect water quality. In this combination, the softener protects your home’s plumbing and appliances, while the RO system ensures your drinking water is clean, safe, and great-tasting.
Cost and installation considerations of water softeners and RO systems
Before investing in a water softener or reverse osmosis system, it’s important to understand the long-term costs as well as the upfront costs. Installation, maintenance, and ongoing expenses can vary widely depending on the type of system and your home’s specific needs.
Cost of a water softener
Installing a water softener typically costs between $500 and $2,500 depending on system size, brand, and whether professional installation is required.
On top of the initial investment, ongoing costs include salt—usually around $300 per year, depending on household water usage and local water hardness. Maintenance is relatively simple but important: periodic cleaning of the brine tank, occasional resin bed replacement every 10–15 years, and regular salt refills to keep the system running smoothly.
Learn more: Water Softener Maintenance 101
When shopping for a unit, look for features that boost efficiency and save money over time. Models with demand-initiated regeneration only regenerate when needed, reducing water and salt usage. Upflow brining systems are even more efficient, using less salt by more effectively recharging the resin beads. While DIY installation is possible for experienced homeowners, professional installation is often recommended to ensure proper plumbing connections and settings.
Cost of an RO system
Under-sink RO systems (the most common for home use) typically cost between $150 and $600 upfront. However, reverse osmosis systems come in a few forms, and the cost varies significantly based on scale.
Depending on the brand and model, RO filter and membrane replacements can range from $40 to over $300, which is an important factor in choosing the system that will best fit your needs. These systems are relatively easy to install under a kitchen sink and require minimal maintenance beyond changing filters and occasional sanitization.
Efficiency is another factor to consider. Traditional RO systems can waste several gallons of water for every gallon filtered, but models with permeate pumps can significantly reduce that waste while improving filtration speed and output pressure.
Expert tips for choosing the right system
Choosing the right water treatment system goes beyond just picking a product. It’s about understanding how your water source, household needs, and installation details all work together. These expert tips will help you make a smarter, more efficient decision for your home and family needs.
Installation order matters
If you plan to install both a water softener and a reverse osmosis system, the order of installation is critical. Always install the water softener first, upstream of the RO unit. This protects the RO membrane from mineral scaling caused by hard water, which can quickly reduce its lifespan and efficiency. Softening the water beforehand allows the RO system to work more effectively and last longer, saving you money on membrane replacements and improving water output.
Maintenance and long-term considerations
Both systems require regular upkeep to stay effective. For water softeners, this includes checking salt levels monthly, cleaning the brine tank occasionally, and replacing resin beds every 10–15 years.
RO systems, on the other hand, need filter changes every 6–12 months and membrane replacement every 2–3 years. Skipping maintenance can lead to poor performance, lower water quality, and even system failure.
When comparing systems, think beyond the initial purchase price. Calculate total cost of ownership, which includes replacement parts, filter cartridges, salt or potassium refills, and labor if you’re hiring professionals. Well-maintained systems can last over a decade, so it’s smart to factor in the long game. Set a calendar reminder for filter changes or invest in systems with filter change indicators or smart monitoring apps that alert you when service is due.
Water source: well vs. city water
Your home’s water source plays a significant role in determining the right solution. Well water often contains high levels of hardness, iron, sediment, bacteria, or even sulfur—so a softener alone usually isn't enough. Testing your water is essential to identify specific contaminants and select the right combination of treatment systems. In many cases, well water may require a softener, RO unit, sediment pre-filter, and UV sterilizer for safe, clean water.
City water, on the other hand, is typically treated but can still carry chlorine, chloramines, lead from pipes, and other byproducts. An RO system is often the perfect complement to municipal water, especially if you’re concerned about taste, odor, or health effects from chemical additives.
Before you invest, get a comprehensive water test from a certified lab—not just a basic strip test. It’ll help you understand exactly what your water needs and avoid over- or under-treating.
Learn more: Lab Water Tests vs At-Home Water Test Kits
Choosing between a water softener or reverse osmosis system
Water softeners and reverse osmosis systems each tackle unique challenges, but when combined, they offer a powerful, whole-home water treatment solution. Whether you’re on city water or relying on a private well, understanding your water quality and choosing the right combination of systems can make a big difference.
Ready to improve your water? Explore our selection of water softeners, RO systems, and expert resources to find the perfect fit for your home.
You might also like: